Miami newspaper praised Singapore’s obsession with education
From our Correspondent
An influential newspaper in Miami, a southern city of the U.S. had lavish generous praise on Singapore’s education system and its “national obsession” with education. (read article here)
Andre Oppenheimer, a columnist of the Miami Herald went on a study trip to Singapore to learn why Singapore’s students score so well on international science and maths tests. He came back visibly impressed and inspired by what he saw.
During his weeklong visit, Oppenheimer was literally blown away by Singapore’s public libraries at malls, big media headlines about students who excel academically and even Singapore’s ubiquitous 2-dollar note, which shows students in a classroom listening to a professor, with a university in the background.
Oppenheimer wrote that there are “ some things that Latin America, a region that has some of the world’s lowest education standards, could learn here.”
“Only four decades ago, when Singapore was told by Great Britain that it could no longer remain a British colony, Singapore was so poor — and hopeless — that no other country was interested in taking it over. Its per capita income at the time was the same as Jamaica’s.
Today, largely thanks to its focus on education, Singapore is the world’s ninth-richest country in per capita income. Comparatively, the United States is 10th, Mexico 82nd and Jamaica 123rd,” he wrote.
Oppenheimer noted that Singapore ranks No. 1 in several categories of the Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS), test of fourth- and eighth-graders’ abilities in math and science.
While Singapore students were first in science in the TIMSS test, U.S. students ranked eighth. Most Latin American countries rank so low in broader international academic tests that they don’t dare participate in the TIMSS.
Oppenheimer attributed Singapore’s successful education system to its founder and ex-Prime Minister Mr Lee Kuan Yew who made English the first language to be used in all Singapore schools in addition to their mother tongues which are relegated to being a second language.
Under Lee’s leadership, Singapore’s education system was transformed into one of the world’s toughest academic meritocracies, where children are ranked by their academic performance, from first to last starting from Primary 1.
The discipline of Singapore students also left a lasting impression on the American journalist. He observed that whenever a visitor turned up in class, the students will bow automatically. They wear uniforms all the way through community college-like technical schools. Mohawk haircuts, dyed hair, jewelry or baggies are a no-no, even in junior college.
Singapore’s Education Minister Ng Eng Hen told him in an interview that technical schools or ITEs are the “jewels of his crown”.
“Almost all countries have good universities, but few have a system of good vocational schools,” he quipped.
The high education level of Singapore is fast becoming its Achilles’ heel. Because of their proficiency in the English language, Singaporeans are one of the highest prized and mobile workers in the world.
According to government sources, there are as many as 145,000 Singaporeans working or studying overseas.
In a survey done byExperiences 2009, the organiser of an annual US education convention, of 153 Singaporean undergraduates at 15 top US universities, as many as 79 per cent prefer to work in US after they graduate. Only 18.1 per cent want to return to Singapore immediately after they complete their studies. (read Asiaone report here)
The brain drain suffered by Singapore is getting considerable for the government to set up an “Overseas Singapore Portal” to keep in touch with Singaporeans living overseas.
In the last two years, the Minister of Home Affairs Mr Wong Kan Seng went on a tour of a few countries with significant numbers of Singaporeans such as Australia, Britain and even far-flung Uganda to remind them to “keep the Singapore flag flying high.”
In a way, Singapore is becoming a victim of its own success. Well educated and skilled Singaporeans are in a position to tap on the increasingly globalized and competitive labor market to seek better opportunities to improve their lives. Many often do not return after living overseas for a number of years.
Source: Miami Herald
11 Responses to “Miami newspaper praised Singapore’s obsession with education”
Alex Tan Allan Ooi AWARE Chee Soon Juan Chiam See Tong Claire Lee David Widjaja DBS Dr Allan Ooi Dr Silviu Ionescu Dr Vivian Balakrishnan Foyce Le Xuan highnote5 Hong Lim Park Jack Lin Xinli Jack Neo Jack Neo affair Jack Neo scandal Josie Lau Josie Lau Meng Lee Lee Kuan Yew Lehman brothers Lighthouse Evangelism MAS minibonds Miss Singapore World NTU stabbing PAP Pastor Rony Tan Ris Low Romanian diplomat in hit-and-run Rony Tan S-League silviu ionescu Singapore Singapore 2010 Youth Olympic Games Tan Kin Lian Thio Su Mien Tiger Woods affair Tong Kok Wai Top 8 Vivian Balakrishnan Wendy Chong Y O G Youth Olympic Games
WP Cumulus Flash tag cloud by Roy Tanck and Luke Morton requires Flash Player 9 or better.








They ARE likely to think otherwise. Because … Life IS MORE THAN …
1. Just literally “SMASHING” a week school holidays of like now from Sept 7-11 … By LOADING teachers AND students with work and classes respectively!
2. How many in our psecondary and even primary school really have MEANINGFULLLL ‘School Holidays” Studying ISN”T THE SAME as working … AS …
3. This ONLY 1 Week achool ‘holidays’ ARE NOT even ONE holiday AT ALL!!! … AS
4. It IS being ‘BURNT’ UP by more marking of papers … ADDITIONAL Classes … ESPECIALLY FOR … “O level” students .. AND EVEN Primary School children ARE NOT SPARED!!! …
5. Especially like this pap-talk-talk govt ministers with MM right at the top ONLY “talking-down” … and thus with little or no pressure unto him!!!
6. Teachers here are stressed out … by INCREASING AutoNoMous School Principals … FULLY GIVEN Descretionary Decision ‘POWERS’ by the MOE and thus IT IS from the Education Minister … indeed it WAS FROM the last one … Shagunaratnam who if Finance Minister … AS …
7. I’ve had younger teachers in their 30s express about seriously wanting to migrate with their spouse and children to for example Australia (favourite) … New Zealand Other favourite … California USA (Despite knowing of “The St. Adreas Fault eearthquake potential anytime) … AND THE ONLY “Pull-Back’ factor IS their ageing parents!!!
8. And this IS NOT ONLY happening in our Eductaion Sector …
9. We ARE LOSING professionals in other sectors as well …
10. And SO … ARE WE …really needing FTs ONLY??? …
11. OR … ALSO Replacing OUR OWN LOST TO OTHER “Less STRESFULLLL and MORE Holistic” Countries TOO???
NEED WE SAY MORE in response to Miami???
As someone who has lived in Miami, I’d like to state two things:
(1) Most state-level and city-level American newspapers aren’t really that good- the Miami Herald included.
(2) Miami suffers from particular problems that impact its educational system. Basically, they have a HUGE number of legal and illegal immigrants from Latin America. In many cases, students in school can’t even speak English, and have traumatic childhoods. I know this, because for a time, I was working with an organization that was trying to help many of these kids. The Miami school system will take in children regardless of whether the child is an illegal alien.
Odds are, the Miami Herald editor’s perception of our ability to do well in international tests failed to take these unique issues of the Miami system into account.
Cecil Chua
Any foreigners who praised our system are free to migrate to become a citizen of Singapore (oh and please volunteer to join SAF if you are male too). You can then send your children to our “first-class education” schools (don’t cheat by sending them to international schools).
Lived for 10-20 years, THEN you can comment.
Disneyland also looked wonderful too as a visitor, doesn’t mean you want to live in one.
what a waste….
please refer to below:
http://scientific-child-prodigy.blogspot.com/2009/09/contrast-of-cultures.html
(mein apologies to the author for taking it from his/her blog)
If einstein was born in singapore…he would either become a comformist drone else leave singapore too.
If another einstein is born in singapore…the local education system will probably have destroyed his natural born intelligence to make sure he becomes another borg [star trek].
I use to have a friend who is really intelligent…too bad he left singapore 14 years ago cos his intelligence was not appreciated…now he is a space rocket scientist in NASA : ) … happy for him.
[...] Excerpt from: Miami newspaper praised Singapore's obsession with education : The … [...]
What about the untold misery behind the ’success’ story?
Am suprise that the Miami Herald’s journalist was here for a weekend and praised our education system. Our children in child-care centers and kintergartens are being pressurised to excel in school work! Many parents are so afraid of their children lagging behind that they send their pre-school children to various tuitions! Depriving children of their childhood is bad for their developments. As rightly pointed out by Sturmtruppen’s comment that a singaporean Einstein will not be given the chance to develop. For a small country like ours depriving late developers like Einstein will be a great loss to the country.
How many of Noble prizes can Singapore claim? none. Any invention that can change the world? none. Is there room for another young Steven Spielberg, air space for Wright brothers, roads for Henry ford, Issac Newton, Bill Gates, Steve Jobs, Thomas Edison ect. NO. They will die from educational expectation and pressure before they can develop. Most will be weighed down by high living cost before they can make it in life. What is the point in life if our children with all the knowledge in the world cannot capitalize it? Steve Jobs and gates did not graduate? Education is only a process that we give to our lovely children for them to gain knowledge while enjoying,hopefully they will be successful, realizing their dream and true potential in life.
What is surprise that the journalist focus is only on academic results and nothing else?
Most kids here are not known to be creative.
Blah, this is just helicopter journalism. Sure, he didn’t do a hatchet job but why over-validate anyway with these heated responses?
FTR I don’t think he was praising at all. He was fascinated, for sure, but then couldn’t resist a snide remark at the end (despite it being a eyewitness account). Definitely not a convert.
The “lesson learning” theme is similar to how SG politicians preached about the Asian Tsunami or Sichuan Earthquake: i.e. informally address to a local audience about something exceptional far away. Doesn’t make the expounder an expert or necessarily with verisimilitude.
What is there to attract the educated to stay in Singapore?
[...] Oppenheimer attributed Singapore’s successful education system to its founder and ex-Prime Minister Mr Lee Kuan Yew who made English the first language to be used in all Singapore schools in addition to their mother tongues which are …Read More [...]